While both Toyota and Lexus enjoy a solid reputation for reliability, Toyota clearly has the advantage when it comes to overall ownership costs. Value-focused customers lean towards Toyota for its well-known affordability in maintenance and reliability. Lexus, sharing Toyota’s foundation, aims for a premium experience with more luxurious features and a higher starting price, but it is equally dependable. The question arises: does a higher upfront cost translate to higher long-term expenses?
Advertisement
According to maintenance data from CarEdge, Toyota’s average maintenance over a decade is roughly $5,996, while Lexus owners face an average of $7,786. This almost $1,800 difference makes Toyota the winner in keeping ownership costs low. Additionally, Toyota vehicles have a slightly lower incidence of major repairs (14.97% compared to Lexus’s 18.75%).
A 2023 analysis by BusinessDay ranks both Toyota and Lexus among the most affordable brands to maintain, with their maintenance costs being 13.41% and 12.3% of purchase price, respectively. For those on a tighter budget, Toyota presents a better option as it combines reliability with less financial commitment in the long run, even though Lexus is recognized as one of the premier luxury car brands.
Advertisement
Why Toyota remains the budget-friendly champ
Toyota’s philosophy revolves around quality engineering, widespread part availability, and a comprehensive dealer network, resulting in significantly lower repair and labor costs. On average, Toyota owners can expect maintenance costs between $5,996 to $9,000 over a decade—substantially less than many rivals. This makes Toyota a perennial choice for commuters, families, and fleet managers due to its affordability and impressive reliability.
Advertisement
In addition to lower maintenance costs, Toyota offers many hybrid and fuel-efficient options, like the Prius and RAV4 Hybrid, which further decreases overall ownership costs. Although not as low as Lexus, insurance premiums are typically more affordable for Toyota models, along with reasonable depreciation rates.
While Toyota has a 14.97% chance of requiring a major repair, it’s still 9.66% lower than the average for other automakers in this category. Toyota repairs tend to be simpler and cheaper compared to Lexus models, which feature more sophisticated technology and materials.
Lexus delivers premium value, but at a premium price
Even with higher ownership costs compared to Toyota, Lexus remains a strong player in the luxury market. It is, in fact, the second cheapest luxury brand to own, just behind Tesla, with ownership expenses equaling about 12.3% of the purchase price. With an average ownership cost of $7,786—possibly reaching around $12,000—it’s not the most economical choice. Yet, against a backdrop of rising ownership costs among German luxury brands, it appears quite reasonable.
Advertisement
Lexus achieves this by marrying Toyota’s reliability with premium quality. The brand also excels in minimizing the likelihood of significant repairs, at 18.75%, which is a remarkable 17.33% better than its rivals. Lexus vehicles, particularly the RX and ES models, hold strong resale values. While Lexus may have a higher initial purchase price, its impressive long-term durability and more affordable maintenance costs offer good value within the luxury segment.
Lexus strikes a balance for drivers seeking comfort and sophistication without the associated high costs of luxury ownership. Although Lexus offers considerable value in the luxury market, Toyota is undoubtedly the better choice for those prioritizing affordability.
Advertisement